UCSD January 2006 Special Election

I’d like to comment on the special election that’s been taking place this week.  The election is being held as a student referendum on the whole Student Run Television drama that’s been gripping this school for the past several months.  If you want the full story, ask someone else, since I don’t really know much about it (or much else about campus politics.  Sorry.  I can tell you what’s happening in the Senate race in Minnesota, though!  Just not what’s happening in my own backyard.).


What I do know is SRTV was shut down because some administrators and student officers objected to content.  That content is widely assumed to be the porn/nudity shown by Steve York (though the actual shutdown was during a political talk show).  Of course, say the magic words “porn”, “nudity”, or “sex”, and the brain-dead social conservative reactionaries go into a tizzy.  And the same breed of brain-dead social conservative reactionaries outside of UCSD descended on our campus like vultures looking for the stinking carrion that is the political issue of porn. (Apparently – though I can’t attest to this personally – even FOX News came to document the slow-motion kabuki show.  Seriously, don’t these guys have anything better to cover?) Like any good controversy, the issue was adorned with a lovely shroud of ignorance and misconceptions; for example, contrary to popular belief, SRTV is not paid with “taxpayer money” but by A.S. student fees.


Apparently none of these ditherheads ever heard of – hmm, I dunno – the FUCKING FIRST AMENDMENT?!!!  Say all you want about how “nasty” the porn was, but this is student-run television, and it should be student-run.  That means that the students who run it should be able to show and tell whatever they – we – damn please.  Don’t like it?  Well fuck you and shut up, because you’re (I’m talking to the outsider reactionaries and school administrators not on the A.S. Council) not in charge.  And you can’t roll out the usual “oh we need to protect our poor children’s innocent minds” (which is already a dubious-at-best argument) because SRTV is closed-circuit and I don’t think we have any seven-year olds on campus.


So the referendum before us consists of two questions.


Do you vote to override the ASUCSD Council’s adoption of the following amendments to the SRTV Charter:

Bill 119, approved October 26, 2005
SRTV Rules and Regulations
C. Indecent Broadcast Restrictions:
3. Graphic depictions of sexual activity involving nudity are not permitted at any time.

Bill 120, approved October 26, 2005
SRTV Charter
1. This Charter will expire no later than March 8, 2006.

SRTV Rules and Regulations
E. Expiration
1. These Rules and Regulations will expire no later than March 8, 2006.

I will vote Yes.  There is no justification in my mind for the blatant censorship that “Indecent Broadcast Restrictions” calls for.  These amendments are a direct attack on student activity and the freedom of speech and expression we as Americans hold dear.  I can’t put it any more simply or succinctly.  These restrictions are wrong, plain and simple, and I will vote to abrogate them.


Do you vote to override the ASUCSD Council’s adoption of the following resolution:

        Bill 150, approved November 2, 2005

A Bill to Enforce the SRTV Charter and Rules and Regulations

WHEREAS, Steven W. York is defined as a “producer” by Article C, Section 2 of the Charter of SRTV, a service of the Associated Students, and;

WHEREAS, the above mentioned article of the SRTV Charter states that producers are “held responsible for their own actions,” and;

WHEREAS, Steven W. York, Stevie Why Productions, and Koala TV produced and broadcasted a graphic depiction of sexual activity involving nudity on October 27, 2005 in violation of the SRTV Charter and Rules and Regulations, and;

WHEREAS, the A.S. Council is entitled to resolve non-compliance with the SRTV Charter and Rules and Regulations, and;

WHEREAS, the A.S. Council administers SRTV as a non-public media forum through the implementation of the SRTV Charter and Rules and Regulations, THEN

BE IT ORDERED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE ASSOCIATED STUDENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO THAT effective immediately, Steven W. York, Stevie Why Productions, and Koala TV are barred from utilizing in any way or entering the premises of SRTV, a service of the Associated Students, and that productions emanating from these aforementioned groups and people are strictly forbidden to be aired on SRTV, and;

BE IT ALSO ORDERED BY THE COUNCIL THAT the Station Managers of SRTV shall actively enforce this order of the Council consistent with their managerial responsibilities laid out in the SRTV Charter and Rules and Regulations, and;

BE IT FINALLY ORDERED BY THE COUNCIL THAT the Commissioner of Student Services shall hold the ultimate authority to enforce this order and shall also have as his or her discretion all appropriate means and resources to enforce this order.

I will vote Yes.  What is UCSD, a police state?  I don’t care how you feel about Steve York – this resolution is wrong and must be overturned.  I am indifferent to him, his productions, or to the actual content of SRTV itself, having never actually watched it, but for me this is not an issue of the person or the thing – it’s an issue of the right to free speech and expression, no matter who’s doing it or what s/he’s showing.  To explicitly exile York from SRTV when, at least originally, he was able to broadcast his material legitimately is a direct slap in the face of the idea that interested and committed students are entitled to submit their work in the marketplace of ideas.


A hundred years ago, Evelyn Beatrice Hall wrote a summation of the French philosopher Voltaire’s attitude towards different kinds of speech that included the famous words “I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it”.  Today, the would-be tyrants of UCSD are saying “I disapprove of what you say so you’re gonna shut the fuck up.”  Well it’s time to shut them the fuck up.  Vote Yes on both resolutions in this election.

liberalmaverick’s Xanga Table of Contents III

For columns dating from January 15 2005 and earlier, see the Table of Contents in the January 25 2005 Xanga entry.


Punching Holes: April 3 2005

Republicans Are Drilling In The Federal Budget And Pristine Wilderness Alike


Judd Gregg: Budgetary Asshole : April 5 2005

New Senate Budget Committee Chairman Proves To Be A Two-Faced Fiscal Hypocrite – In Other Words, Your Typical Republican


Democratic Alternative To Punching Holes: April 7 2005

Democrats Believe In A Strong And Fiscally Responsible Budget


The Decrepit State Of The UCSD Student Center: April 13 2005

“Old” Center Of Student-Run Small Business Gives Way To Corporate Price Center


A Test of Principle: April 26 2005
Amazingly Enough, The DLC Makes Sense On Estate Taxes


My Last Night As A Minor: May 9 2005

I’m Turning Eighteen!


Friday The 13th: May 14 2005

Sun God!  Ludacris!


Lessons From The First Year Of College: June 18 2005

So Freshman Year’s Over.  Let’s Recap.


Warren Writing: Liberal Propaganda Machine? : July 8 2005

Despite My Liberal Leanings, I Question The Legitimacy Of A Writing Program Acting As A Leftist Mouthpiece


Apartment 2227 Idiosyncrasies: July 19 2005


Douchebag Of Liberty: August 5 2005

Poor Robert Novak


My MTV Rant: August 25 2005
The Sad State Of Music Television


The Lessons Of Katrina: September 19 2005

Hurricane Shows How Important Government And Readiness Really Are


October 18 2005 Rant: October 18 2005


Election 2005: November 8 2005

I Get To Vote For The First Time!  Yay!


Bill O’Reilly says FUCK YOU to San Francisco: November 11 2005

Yeah?  Well FUCK YOU too.


Porn Nation: November 22 2005

Man In Personal Crisis Finds Recovery In Religion


Thanksgiving…Ugh: November 25 2005


PANS: December 6 2005


The Politics Of 2005 – Part I: The Legislation Of 2005: December 19 2005


The Politics Of 2005 – Part II: The Political Battlefields: December 20 2005


The Politics Of 2005 – Part III: Looking Further Ahead: December 21 2005


The Politics Of 2005 – Part IV: Winning In Suburbia: December 23 2005


The Politics Of 2005 – Part V: You Want Ideas? I’ll Give You Ideas! : December 27 2005


The Politics Of 2005 – Part VI: The Big Ideology: December 28 2005